STOP MARKETING TO EVERYONE. IT'S WHY NOBODY'S LISTENING.

Updated: Nov 9
Ask ten small-business owners who their ideal customer is, and at least a few will say, “honestly, anyone who'll buy.” It makes sense. Turning people away feels like leaving money on the table.
But here's the catch: marketing aimed at everyone usually lands with no one. A message built for “anyone” ends up specific enough for nobody, and it shows up as flat engagement, muddy ad copy, and a website that could belong to half a dozen different businesses.

YOU'RE NOT ALONE IN THIS
Turns out, most businesses are flying a little blind here. According to Pollfish, 2022, 82.4% of the business owners and executives surveyed admitted they don't confidently know their customers' pain points, and 68.6% said they don't really understand how their customers think. That's not a knock on anyone's business sense, it's just genuinely hard to zoom out and study your own customers from the inside.
The good news: this is one of the most fixable problems in small-business marketing. You don't need a research department or a six-week project. You need about twenty honest minutes and the right questions.
WHY "EVERYONE" DOESN'T WORK AS A STRATEGY
Picture two ads for the same coffee shop. One says, “Great coffee for everyone!” The other says, “The spot downtown workers duck into for a 10-minute reset between meetings.” The second one stops more scrolling thumbs, because it sounds like it's talking to someone specific instead of shouting into a crowd.
That's the whole trick. A target audience isn't about excluding people who might buy from you, plenty of folks outside your “ideal customer” will still walk in. It's about giving your marketing one specific person to talk to, so the words, the photos, and the offer all sound like they mean it.
THREE QUESTIONS THAT CUT THROUGH THE GUESSWORK
You don't need a 40-page customer avatar worksheet. Three honest answers will get you most of the way there.
Who already buys from you, and what do they have in common? Think age, job, neighborhood, or the specific problem that brought them in.
What do they complain about elsewhere? The delay, the price, or the lousy experience that sent them looking for someone like you instead.
Where do they actually spend their attention? Scrolling Instagram on a lunch break, reading a neighborhood Facebook group, or opening a text instead of an email.
Write the answers down in plain language, even just a sentence or two. “Busy parents in their 30s who are tired of dentist offices that make their kid cry” tells you more about what to post, what to say, and where to say it than “women, 25 to 45” ever will.
WHAT CHANGES ONCE YOU ACTUALLY KNOW
Once you can picture the actual person you're talking to, everything downstream gets easier. Your captions stop sounding like a press release. Your ad budget stops spreading thin across people who were never going to buy anyway. Even your homepage gets easier to write, because you already know what that one person needs to hear first.
None of this means turning away customers who don't fit the mold exactly, it means your marketing finally has someone specific to talk to. Which, it turns out, is how you end up reaching more of the right people, not fewer.
If you're staring at a blank page trying to answer those three questions, that's exactly the kind of conversation we love having. At 99 Media, figuring out who you're actually talking to is step one of every strategy we build, before a single graphic gets made or a single post goes live. Reach out, and let's get specific.



Comments